PostHeaderIcon Hot Heads Over Hot Pots

Ancient Egyptian potsLittle do millennial-old Roman, Greek, Chinese and Egyptian vases, pots, precious jade objects encased in museum vitrines know what trouble they have unleashed in modern times.  For at least the past 25 years, museums, dealers and collectors have found themselves under verbal and legal attack from archeologists and source countries, accused of encouraging looting and illegal trafficking in  ancient treasures.

One example of the hot-tempered dispute involved UNESCO, the cultural and educational arm of the United Nations, which adopted a 1970 cut-off date for the acquisition of antiquities while most American art museums followed a 1983 trading deadline. Finally, in 2008, the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD) adopted the UNESCO date as governing future dealings.  Objects now must possess evidence of legal provenance prior to 1970. Objects offered for sale after that date, such as looted artifacts from Iraq, may not be acquired.

Source nations have argued successfully in recent years for the return of ancient artifacts that were illegally removed from their countries. Thus, the Metropolitan Museum, the Getty, Cleveland and Boston museums have returned objects to Italy and other countries of origin.

Besides the dating controversy, some museum directors believe that  encyclopedic museums such as the Louvre, the British Museum, the Met and the Art Institute of Chicago are the places best suited to conserve and display such objects to advance the public’s understanding of the artistic triumphs of earlier civilizations.

James Cuno, director of the Art Institute, authored a book entitledWho Owns Antiquity? wherein he advanced such a claim and also argued that nations advocating restrictive retention and aggressive return policies were practicing a form of cultural nationalism that was more politically than artistically-driven.

Last month, Timothy Rub, now head of the Philadelphia Museum of Art and a member of the AAMD panel that adopted the earlier cut-off date toward the collection of antiquities, spoke before a panel at the College Art Association convention in Chicago and offered his own nuanced prescription for how museums should behave.

He distanced himself from Cuno’s defense of the universal museum as the best repository (a minority view among museum directors) but also tiptoed away from archeologists’ claim that antiquities have little value independent of their archeological context, meaning resting in the ground at their original location.

Trying to skirt the thicket surrounding such loaded terms as “ownership”, “custodianship” and “nation vs. object-oriented” policies, Rub said that, “if one has to choose, museums have a greater responsibility for stewardship…than they do for the ownership of objects.”  This is the concept under which the Met and the Getty engineered long-term loan agreements with Italy.  Stewardship may offer the best way out of the conceptual maze surrounding antiquities.

Where museums have collected in the past but can no longer acquire post-1970 materials, Rub advocated “stronger collaborative relationships” and the commitment of “greater institutional resources” (most likely money and conservation services) with source countries in order to gain access to the objects.

Little by little, museums are inching toward greater accommodation with the arguments of source nations and archeologists. Perhaps one day, both sides will declare a final truce though that prospect remains a hopeful gleam.

19 Responses to “Hot Heads Over Hot Pots”

  • David Gill says:

    Timothy Rub could have commented on the return of antiquities to Italy from the Cleveland Museum of Art.

  • Lise says:

    Nice blog here! Also your website loads up fast! What host are you using? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

  • Hello admin! I have a small request. I was just searching for some information on the topic and found this post. Some really nice stuff you shared here. Can I please share this post on my new website I’m currently workin on? Pretty please:) I will check back again later to see what you answered. cheers, Drew Lopez.

  • Wonderful, neat work! Happy I came across your article first to have read this!

  • I am glad to be one of many visitants on this outstanding internet site (:, thankyou for putting up.

  • Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!

  • –‘ I am very thankful to this topic because it really gives useful information “,*

  • Interesting post i totally agree with other commenters. Keep writing

  • Backlinks says:

    Right on Brother, great layout, nice opinions, fantastic blog. one in a million. 🙂

  • Perfect work you have done, this site is really cool with fantastic info .

  • Outstanding post, you have pointed out some excellent details , I as well believe this s a very excellent website.

  • Sweet website , super style and design , really clean and apply friendly .

  • I real delighted to find this internet site on bing, just what I was searching for : D as well saved to fav.

  • Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn anything like this before. So good to find any individual with some unique ideas on this subject. realy thanks for starting this up. this web site is something that’s wanted on the web, somebody with a little originality. helpful job for bringing something new to the internet!

  • lg rumor says:

    Very superb info can be found on web site.

  • I am lucky that I observed this web site, exactly the right info that I was searching for! .

  • cheap webcam says:

    I am glad to be one of the visitors on this outstanding internet site (:, thanks for putting up.

  • Mysore City says:

    Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is great blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.

  • Myelitecn87e says:
    Buying a used or new vehicle could be a tough approach if you do not know what you are carrying out. By educating yourself about automobile shopping prior to go to the dealership, you can make points less difficult for yourself. The following advice can help the next purchasing trip be pleasant.

    Constantly deliver a auto mechanic alongside when buying a new vehicle. Auto sellers are notorious for offering lemons and you may not wish to be their after that patient. When you can not have a technician to look at cars along, at least ensure that you have him take a look at closing option before you buy it.

    Know your restrictions. Before starting store shopping for your automobile or pickup truck, decide how much you can afford to spend, and stick to it. Don’t overlook to incorporate desire for your computations. You can expect to shell out all around twenty percent as an advance payment also, so be ready.

    Well before visiting a dealership, know what sort of automobile you want. Analysis most of you alternatives before store shopping so you can determine what works the best for your finances and loved ones demands. Do your homework to learn exactly how much you should be paying to get a possible auto.

    Before signing any contract make time to go through every single collection, such as the small print. When there is something detailed you do not understand, do not indicator before you purchase an answer which you comprehend. Unsavory salesmen can make use of a contract to insert many fees that have been not talked about.

    If you retain the preceding advice in mind the very next time that you simply go buying a car, you will end up more likely to get a full deal. Purchasing a automobile does not have to be a frustration. Use the information with this post and you may have the car you need in a great selling price.

Leave a Reply